AARP Auto Insurance Review 2022

Last modified: March 25, 2022
  • Claims 9
  • Buying 8
  • Coverage Variety 8
  • Value For Money 8
  • Transparency 7
  • Financial Strength A
  • BBB Rating A+
  • Coverages 5/5
  • Flexibility Policy customization available
  • Pricing Competitive pricing
  • Discounts 5/5
  • Support 24/7 roadside assistance, 24/7 claim services, Email, Phone
  • User Ratings Trustpilot 1.9 stars
  • Availability All states

Considering buying AARP Hartford auto insurance? We gathered AARP auto insurance reviews and information in this article. Learn more here.


About the Company

The AARP (formerly known as the American Association of Retired Persons) offers a wide range of insurance products through its insurance partner, the Hartford Group

The company was established in 1958 with the sole purpose of helping individuals aged 50 years and above with their insurance needs.

AARP offers customized auto insurance policies for seniors, along with outstanding additional features. It received good reviews for both claim processing and customer satisfaction. You can contact their customer support via the AARP auto  insurance phone number – 877-805-9918

AARP scored an A on financial stability with S&P and AM Best, which indicates that the company is stable enough to settle claims.                 

Want to know more about this auto insurance company? Our detailed AARP auto insurance reviews will help you in making the final decision.

How We Reviewed

Here is what we did to review the cost and contents of an AARP auto insurance quote.

In order to make our AARP auto insurance review, we collected quotes for 3 age groups in the states of NY, NJ, CL, TX, MI, for a Honda Accord 2015 and some conditions mentioned here in this table:

Age 25-year-old 35-year-old 45-year-old
Car type Honda Accord 2015 Honda Accord 2015 Honda Accord 2015
States NJ, NY, CL, TX, MI NJ, NY, CL, TX, MI NJ, NY, CL, TX, MI
Condition 1 Full and minimum coverage rate Maximum and minimum coverage rate Full and minimum coverage rate
Condition 2 Pre and post-accident rate Pre and post-accident rate Pre and post-accident rate
Condition 3 Excellent and poor credit score rate Excellent and poor credit score rate Excellent and poor credit score rate

Where Is It Available

AARP Auto Insurance covers all U.S. states. You can easily find an agent in areas near you. 

Types of Insurance Covered and Missing Coverages

AARP auto insurance offers various types of coverage, including the following:

Aside from these basic coverage options, AARP also offers the following auto insurance plans:

  • Accident Forgiveness – with this coverage, the premium won’t increase after your first at-fault accident in 5 years. This coverage is not applicable in California. 
  • Disappearing Deductible – for every year with a clean driving record, AARP decreases the deductible on your collision coverage, until you reach zero, or $100 in New York. This coverage is also not applicable to California drivers. 
  • Waiver of Deductible – this is applicable if you are not responsible for the claimed accident. This coverage is available in selected states. 
  • One Deductible – if you are filing a claim to recover loss for two vehicles, both covered by AARP policy, you would only have to pay for the higher deductible. This coverage applies to auto and home insurance in an event where damage has been caused to your car and your house. 
  • Reduction of $100 Collision Deductible – this is applicable if you have selected an AARP-approved repair shop for the damage repair. This coverage is not applicable in all states. 

Insurance Offers or Extras

Aside from the coverages mentioned above, the company offers plenty of discounts. AARP auto insurance discounts are as follows: 

  • AARP Member Discounts – AARP members receive better rates and discounts on auto insurance with affiliated companies. These discounts increase, and the rates get better the longer you have been their member.
  • Lifetime Car Repair Guarantee – if you are making a covered claim and getting repairs done at an AARP approved auto shop, all the repairs are covered as long as you lease or own the car. 
  • New Car Replacement Coverage – in case your new car gets completely totaled within 15,000 miles or 15 months of coverage, then the company offers you a brand new car of the same model and make. 
  • Post-Accident Support (RecoverCare) – the company will reimburse you for up to $2,500 if you sustain injuries in an accident, to assist with home chores if you are not able to do them after the accident. This includes transportation, food prep, lawn mowing, and dog walking. 
  • Rate Lock – when you sign up for a 12-month policy, you will get the following year’s guaranteed rate. 
  • Full Glass Coverage – if your windshield gets damaged, AARP covers repair without any deductible. This is an optional coverage, and it costs an extra premium.
  • Classic Car Coverage – AARP works with you to settle the value for your classic car. The company offers full coverage for classic cars, including underinsured/uninsured motorists, medical payment, physical damage to the classic car, property damage liability, and bodily injury liability. Optional coverage can also be purchased, including spare parts and full glass coverage. 

AARP offers other excellent discounts for customers, including:

  • Discount for vehicles with alternative fuel-types
  • Driver training
  • Good student discount
  • Two or more airbags
  • Anti-theft devices 
  • Paid-in-full discount is also available
  • Bundling policies
  • Successful completion of the defensive driver course

Customer Satisfaction and Reviews

The AARP auto insurance rating for overall customer satisfaction is about average.

The company received more than the expected number of complaints to the state regulators. It still boasts a good rating with BBB for overall customer experience. 

AARP insurance received average ratings for claim satisfaction, which is better than most of its competitors. 

The financial stability of the company has an A with both S&P and AM Best. It has an excellent rating at BBB. 

The company received average ratings with Trustpilot and ConsumerAffairs, but these ratings are still higher than the ratings received by many other auto insurance companies. 

Platform Rating
Trustpilot 1.9 stars
ConsumerAffairs 1.7 stars


Customer Support

There are many easy ways for existing and potential policyholders to get in touch with the company. 

AARP has a number for roadside assistance, a 24/7 helpline, and a separate 24/7 claims service line. The company also offers a different number for the ease of their hearing-impaired clients. 

There is no option for live chat, but there is a customer complaint form available online. 

Aside from that, you can get in touch with the agent near you to resolve your concern. 

You can also file claims, track the progress, and manage, set up, and keep track of your policies online. 

Ease of Use and Policy Customization

The website is easy to use and includes all the relevant information for both existing and potential policyholders. It also has an FAQ section and auto insurance definitions to help explain car insurance easily.  

The company offers a mobile app through which you can manage your policies, pay bills, view insurance ID cards, submit and track claims, and request roadside assistance. You can find an agent or a repair shop near you using the app. 

AARP vehicle insurance offers towing service if your car breaks down, and if your car has to stay in the shop for longer, the company also reimburse you for rental cars. The limit for each day depends on the coverage you have. 

AARP Car Insurance Pricing Review

The average national representative rate of AARP car insurance is $1,332, making it among the most expensive auto insurances available. Of course, the total amount depends on various factors, including your age, driving record, and more. 

The average AARP car insurance cost for:

  • A 25-year-old driver is $1,332
  • A 35-year-old driver is $1,233
  • A 45-year-old driver is $1,100

The average insurance rate for drivers as per the credit score is as follows:

  • For the drivers with good credit, the rate is $1,274 
  • For drivers with fair credit, the rate of $1,380
  • For drivers with poor credit score, the rate is $2,154

Comparison With Competitors

Here is a comparison between AARP auto insurance and a few of its competitors:

AARP Auto Insurance vs Progressive 

Both companies are well-established and are rated among the top auto insurance companies in the country. While both offer great discounts and perks for their customers, AARP’s discounts are limited to AARP members. 

Progressive offers Telematics, Military, and HomeOwner discounts that are not provided by AARP

On the other hand, AARP offers Air Bags, Anti-Lock Brake System, Good driver, Driver training, and Affinity Membership Alum discounts that are not available with Progressive

AARP has good financial strength ratings, and it received a higher rating for customer satisfaction. 

The roadside assistance offered by Progressive is more comprehensive than AARP’s. 

AARP Auto Insurance vs Allstate 

Both companies’ discounts are excellent, but Allstate offers more unique discounts and perks than AARP insurance. 

Allstate offers Pay in Full, Advanced Payment, Student Away at School, Telematics, and New Vehicle discounts not offered by AARP. 

On the other hand, AARP offers Multiple Vehicles discount and Affinity Membership Alum.

AARP has a stronger financial strength as compared to Allstate, and also scored higher in customer satisfaction. 

However, for customer interaction and satisfaction, Allstate scored higher. 

AARP Auto Insurance vs GEICO

GEICO is well-known for its affordable rates and outstanding discounts. It certainly offers better rates than AARP auto insurance. 

GEICO is a better option than AARP if you have a bad credit score. The company offers better rates for drivers with an exceptional credit score. 

For drivers with a DUI, reckless driving violation, ticket, or an at-fault accident in their driving record, GEICO is a good option.

GEICO has a superior financial stability ranking as compared to AARP insurance. 

Claims Handling

You can file a claim through the phone, online, or using the mobile app. 

AARP auto insurance has a 24/7 phone number to file insurance claims, but you can file a simple claim online as well. To file the claim, you will have to add in your policy number, you name, and briefly describe the car accident.

 It is wise to include what exactly happened when it happened, what are the injuries or damage, were there any witnesses, and insurance details of the drivers involved, if possible. 

The company starts investigating the claim and will get in touch with you to explain the process. You can always keep track of your claim status online.

Pros & Cons

The Pros

  • Bundling option and discount
  • 24/7 car insurance claims service
  • Lifetime renewability

The Cons

  • More than average customer complaints
  • Higher rates for risky and young drivers
  • Discounts available for AARP members

Final Verdict

Is AARP a good car insurance company? Our detailed AARP auto insurance reviews can help you make an informed decision. 

AARP is an ideal auto insurance company for AARP members and elderly drivers. The company offers outstanding policy features, discounts, and savings for AARP members, to meet their lifestyles and needs. 

The drawback is that the insurance is limited to ages 50+. This auto insurance is also not for you if you are looking for affordable rates, not being an AARP member. 


Who is eligible for AARP auto insurance coverage?

AARP insurance is only available to people who are age 50 or older. This is because the company bases eligibility on the driver’s age, not their driving history or other risk factors.

How do I find an affordable AARP auto insurance price?

AARP auto insurance prices are not listed on the website. To find the price of AARP auto insurance, call a local agent or broker to get a quote.

How can I file a complaint about my insurance company?

You can submit a complaint against your insurance company by calling the Consumer Affairs Division in your state. If you’re facing any issues right away, try to negotiate a settlement on the spot or with your agent. You’ll be able to get help by filling out our complaint form and providing us with details on how it has affected you.